Thursday, October 8, 2026

Euthanasia (MAiD) by advance request is euthanasia without consent.

Alex Schadenberg
Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

Justice Minister Sean Fraser and Health Minister Marjorie Michel stated on October 7, 2026 that the federal government will introduce legislation, that will prevent the implementation of euthanasia for mental illness as a sole criteria. 

However, the government legislation will also permit euthanasia by advanced request.

The Euthanasia Prevention Coalition opposes killing people but why is euthanasia by advance request even more egregious?

Euthanasia by advanced request is a very dangerous concept as it permits doctors and nurse practitioners to kill someone who has become incompetent, based on an advanced request. The person who is killed requested to be killed while competent but is now incompetent and cannot confirm the request and is not legally capable of changing their minds.

Euthanasia was originally legalized in Canada under the guise of being for mentally competent adults, who are capable of consenting and who freely "choose." Euthanasia by advanced request undermines these basic principles.

Euthanasia by advance request means that a person, while competent, legally declares their "wish" to be killed, and if the person becomes incompetent, the person could then be killed, even though the person is not capable of consenting. Therefore euthanasia by advance request is euthanasia without consent.

Also, once a person becomes incompetent, they are not legally able to change their mind, meaning that some other person will have the right to decide when the person dies, even if that person is living a happy life.

Therefore a person who is approved to die by euthanasia based on an advanced request, who becomes incompetent, will lose their right to change their mind.

This is what happened in the Netherlands with the “coffee euthanasia” death where  an incompetent woman, who had previously requested euthanasia, resisted during the euthanasia. The 
doctor responded by putting a sedative in the woman's coffee but the woman continued to resist, so the doctor had her family hold her down as the doctor completed the lethal poison injection.

If euthanasia by advance request is approved, the law will discriminate against incompetent people who did not make an advance request. The law will be challenged in the court as it will be argued that the person didn't make the advance request based on timing (the option didn't exist yet) or lack of knowledge that it was possible to make an advance request. Will the court, in the future, expand the law even further?

Once killing incompetent people is viewed as "compassionate" it will be considered cruel not to kill an incompetent person who is deemed to be suffering, because the person didn't make an advance request.

Finally, euthanasia by advanced request is outside of the federal government jurisdiction. 
Every Canadian province has advanced directive laws based on their constitutional power over healthcare. 

Québec already expanded their law to allow euthanasia by advanced request. Whereas I oppose euthanasia by advanced request I recognize that based on provincial jurisdiction concerning healthcare, Québec had the right to do so, whereas the federal government does not have the right to do so.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

What would be the point of a federal law if provincially something could override it anyhow? The whole thing is very sad.

Anonymous said...

Why would the family hold down the patient who is struggling to resist euthanasia and live? Is that not murder? Being an accomplice to murder?

Alex Schadenberg said...

Originally the doctor was cleared, then after more public outcry the doctor was prosecuted and the case went to the Dutch High Court and they cleared the doctor and stated that nothing was wrong, the woman wasn't capable of changing her mind.

Margaret said...

So she resisted, but was incapable of changing her mind? Will that not make other crimes against people who cannot communicate legal? After all, they didn't say "No" clearly.

Anonymous said...

Something most definitely is wrong

Anonymous said...

Alex, could you send me info on why the federal government is not to be involved in advanced directives?

Alex Schadenberg said...

Email Alex Schadenberg at alex@epcc.ca

Anonymous said...

Killing is murder. Nothing justifies it. If I am in the hospital, I will ask to see that my request to not be killed under any circumstances written in my file.
I may print on my arm with permanent marker that conscious or not, I don't want to be killed.

Anonymous said...

It sounds like if she could drink her coffee and resist physically, given the opportunity, she could have picked up a pen and written her choice.

Anonymous said...

Alex, thank you for all your work protecting the sanctity of life.
God bless you and yours.

Alex Schadenberg said...

Sorry Anonymous. She was physically capable but she was declared incompetent. The Netherlands High Court decided that nothing wrong had happened because this woman was incompetent and therefore not capable of revoking her advance request.

Anonymous said...

This is outrageous, and will only lead to more relaxed rules on Euthanasia.
ADVANCE REQUESTS!!!!! Who can tell what the future will bring? This is Affective Forecasting (predicting how you will feel emotionally in future scenarios, such as coping with a chronic or severe illness). This type of thinking can produce the Nocebo Effect: (when people experience worsening illnesses through expectations or predicting what might happen). All fallacious thinking undermines Faith, acceptance, and the preciousness of life.