Showing posts with label Disability Discrimination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Disability Discrimination. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Austrian assisted suicide deaths for people with disabilities increasing.

Alex Schadenberg
Executive Director Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

I reported in January 2022 that the language of the Austrian assisted suicide law would lead to expansions and a quick increase in assisted suicide deaths and the recent Austrian assisted suicide report shows that this is happening.

The recent report indicates that there were 198 Austrian assisted suicide deaths in 2025 which was up from 112 in 2024. It should concern the Austrian authorities that there were 108 women and 90 men who died by assisted suicide. What is causing more woman than men to die by assisted suicide?

On October 26 I wrote that the Austrian bill states that chronically or terminally ill adults can make provisions for an assisted suicide. When assisted suicide is permitted for chronically ill people the law will be available primarily for people with disabilities, who have chronic conditions but not otherwise dying.

I reported, after the law had passed, that the Austrian parliament had legalized assisted suicide for people with disabilities. The Austrian law does not differentiate between a chronic physical condition and psychiatric condition.

In January, 2026 Austrian Samuel Prinz-Reiterer (22) announced that he would be dying by assisted suicide on his birthday after living with chronic health issues after a Covid 19 infection.

Based on my assessment of the language of the law, it should not surprise people that assisted suicide is becoming more common.

Assisted suicide allows medical professionals to be directly involved with causing the death of another person. Assisted suicide is always wrong because it concerns the killing of people.

The report also indicated that there were 925 suicide deaths of men and 230 suicide deaths of women in Austria in 2025. This refers to suicide deaths that were not assisted suicides.

Assisted suicide was legalized in Austria after a 2020 court decision that created a "right to suicide." The 2020 court decision said that committing suicide is a right of “self determination” and that obtaining help is part of that right.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Roger Foley continues to seek funding for self-directed care in Ontario.

Alex Schadenberg
Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

Fox news recently featured Roger Foley, a Canadian man who is living in a London Ontario hospital for 10 years as he battles to receive self-directed care funding to enable him to be cared for at home. Foley has been offered euthanasia (MAiD) several times and has been denied food for long periods of time.

Roger is working with several supportive organizations on the Bring Roger Home campaign.

Rachel del Guidice reported for Fox news on October20:
A Canadian man battling a debilitating neurological disease told Fox News Digital that hospital staff repeatedly raised the possibility of medically assisted death while he was fighting for the home care he says he needs to survive.

Roger Foley, who has spinocerebellar ataxia, told Fox News Digital in a recent interview that the conversations began in 2016 at Victoria Hospital, part of the London Health Sciences Centre in Ontario, where he says he has remained hospitalized for years while seeking a self-directed home-care arrangement.

In a July 7, 2026, letter obtained by Fox News Digital, Foley's attending physician said he could safely leave the hospital if the Ontario government authorized an individualized home-care arrangement.
Foley prefers to be cared for in his home, but without the necessary funding he remains in the hospital. Dr George Dresser, Foley's physician, told Fox news in a letter that:
"By any reasonable clinical standard, you could be discharged from our hospital if you had adequate support at home,"
Dresser stated that Foley has complex medical needs that require consistent caregivers and highly individualized assistance. Dresser also stated that home-care would be a much less expensive option and provide much better "matched care."

Foley has been pressured, in the past, to consider euthanasia (MAiD) and he has experienced hospital policies that are not flexible to his needs. del Guidice reported:
Foley also alleged that the hospital removed lighting accommodations for his neurological condition in May 2025, making it difficult for him to receive care and consume food and fluids.

Foley said the lighting dispute is particularly serious because his neurological condition makes him sensitive to certain wavelengths of light, including those emited by fluorescent fixtures.

For years, he said, the hospital accommodated his condition with amber-spectrum lighting that allowed caregivers to assist him without triggering his symptoms.

But in May 2025, Foley alleged the hospital withdrew those accommodations and began requiring staff to provide care under fluorescent lighting.

He claimed the change has made it increasingly difficult to receive routine assistance, including help with eating and drinking, because he must wear large, heavy protective goggles that place additional strain on his already compromised neck.
As a friend of Roger Foley I can assure you that the lighting dispute was real. Hospital staff were ordered to turn the fluorescent lighting on while caring for Roger. Roger went days without effective nourishment because the hospital refused to feed him without turning on the fluorescent lights causing Roger significant pain from the fluorescent lights. At one point I helped Roger improvise ski goggles to enable him to eat with the fluorescent lights on.

Foley has kept his accessible apartment for the last 10 years. He could move back to his apartment if he is approved for self-directed funding. 

Foley is working with several supportive organizations on the Bring Roger Home campaign. Roger is hoping to raise the money needed to cover the extra cost for his care - over and above - what the Ontario government is willing to provide. Foley told del Guidice:
"I'm not giving up," he said. "I don't want to die, my doctors know I don't want to die, my physicians have always been very explicit and direct that it's not safe to put me in that type of close model that I need direct funding."
Once again, the cost of the care that Foley receives in the hospital is far greater than the cost of home-care that would be oriented to his individual needs and yet the Ontario Ministry of Health refuses to approve him for the level of home-care that he needs.

Thursday, September 17, 2026

Lying About Disabled People’s Welfare Is Wrong

By Meghan Schrader
Meghan is a disability activists and a member of the EPC-USA board.

Meghan Schrader
I’ve talked several times on this blog about the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, because it threatens new protections against euthanasia and infanticide. It also contains critical new protections to help disabled people stay in their communities rather than institutions, as well as improvements to internet access, support for disabled parents, etc. These protections directly impact disabled people’s quality of life, declines in which contribute to euthanasia, suicide and/or medical neglect.

The Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit takes the position that implementing the new community integration clarifications is “burdensome” to states. It asks the government to strike these regulations from the final rule and let disabled people shoulder the burden of being coerced into institutions for state convenience.

Alas, the Department of Justice, along with five other states, has joined a proposed resolution to the lawsuit in which the United States District Court Northern District of Texas would rule that the government must drop the community integration protections from the 2024 Final Rule. 

But I think that many EPC blog readers may not be aware of this.

To address this issue I have to mention the debate about whether the law should define gender dysphoria as a disability, but I’m also putting that issue aside for now, not because it isn’t something important that impacts vulnerable people, but to help EPC blog readers understand what the lawsuit actually says.

The original version of the lawsuit was partially precipitated by a section of the Final Rule that defined gender dysphoria as a disability and the lawsuit mentioned that, along with asking the government to vitiate all of the new protections in the Final Rule and Section 504 itself. Yet regardless of what one believes about whether Section 504 ought to define gender dysphoria as a disability, the President’s EO on gender identity issues specifically says that gender dysphoria is not a disability. That means that that provision of the Final Rule will not be enforced.

So, several states dropped out of the lawsuit and the lawsuit was amended to contest the rest of the Final Rule, especially its community integration mandate.

Since January of 2026, the lawsuit has not mentioned gender dysphoria at all; the text of the lawsuit makes this clear. Yet when agreeing to drop out of the amended lawsuit in May, Indiana’s attorney general wrote this on his Facebook page:

“With the Trump Administration’s swift action to reverse Biden’s unlawful expansion of Section 504, we have voluntarily dismissed our claims in a multi state lawsuit. Section 504 was never meant to advance a radical and woke agenda. It exists to protect Americans with real physical, intellectual, and developmental disabilities-not include gender dysphoria at the expense of those that need support.”
This statement is not accurate. The version of the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit that Indiana dropped out of in May 2026 says nothing about gender dysphoria.

Surely Indiana’s AG was aware of that, since it’s his responsibility to be apprised of the content of his own lawsuit.

Unfortunately, that statement seems like an attempt to hide the lawsuit’s contents from people in his political orbit who may agree that Section 504 shouldn’t define gender dysphoria as a disability, but might not be cool with coercing nonviolent disabled people into institutions.

Indiana’s AG is not the only government official erroneously claiming that the lawsuit was restricted to gender dysphoria; I’ve seen other AGs do it as well.

But aside from impacting disabled people who identify as all different genders and hold different beliefs about gender dysphoria-related policies, the lawsuit no longer has anything to do with gender dysphoria. 

It has to do with arbitrarily coercing disabled Americans of all socioeconomic backgrounds into institutions so that state officials can direct their energy and money to things other than community support. That’s it.

Lying is wrong, and lying about coercing disabled people into institutions for state convenience violates society’s moral obligations to persons with disabilities. 

Monday, August 31, 2026

“Euthanasia And Arbitrary Institutionalization Are Both Immoral”

Meghan Schrader
By Meghan Schrader
Meghan is a disability activists and a member of the EPC-USA board.

As I’ve said, I think that one of the most effective ways to prevent euthanasia is for euthanasia opponents to be thinking about what kind of world we want people with disabilities to live in, and do what we can to link euthanasia prevention to creating a better world. 

Hence, I think it’s valuable for euthanasia opponents to be aware of the trend towards broad re-institutionalization that is happening in the United States right now, especially since we know that coerced institutionalization contributes to euthanasia.

Institutions often smell like pee. The odor of urine hangs in the air. If you live in an institution you might get the chance to do something fun once in a while, like make a craft or watch a TV show, but your options for recreation are limited. Your loved ones and friends might come visit you at designated hours. You eat whatever food the institution serves. Often if you want to go to the bathroom, an orderly will have to unlock the door for you. Maybe the person living in the room next to you screams constantly. Maybe your roommate died from a bedsore that became infected because there weren’t enough staff to take care of his needs. 

In many ways living in an institution is like living in prison, except the residents generally aren’t criminals.

So, as a euthanasia prevention advocate, I’m disturbed that apparently, that’s the world that Texas, Florida, Alaska, and the Department of Justice want for some disabled people.

As I’ve noted, a 1999 SCOTUS precedent called Olmstead LC. generally requires states to provide community supports to disabled people who would be unnecessarily institutionalized without them. Ie, SCOTUS held that there may be some people who do need institutionalization in a humane setting, like if they are homicidal, have no ability to care for themselves whatsoever or prefer to live in an institution. But within reason, states can't put disabled people in institutions because states prefer that to community support. This determination created Olmstead’s “community integration mandate,” which helps protect disabled people from living in institutions just because that’s where the supports are.

But now, Texas, Florida, Alaska and the DOJ are fighting to let states design their home and community support systems in a way that would make many disabled people unable to receive the support they need without living in an institution.

This would be the case even when the disabled people aren’t a threat to themselves or others.

Florida, Texas and Alaska are the three states still clinging to the aforementioned Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit. The lawsuit threatens euthanasia-preventing healthcare protections for disabled people, but especially takes aim at simple, straightforward 2024 guidance about how to implement Olmstead’s mandate that disabled people who aren’t a threat to themselves or others be able to receive services in their communities.

These guidelines were also outlined by DOJ guidance in 2011 and 2020 and aren’t complicated: they define what community integration means and what states must do to achieve it. The regulations define what it means to be at risk of unnecessary institutionalization, and clarify that disabled people need not wait until they are unnecessarily institutionalized to invoke their right to community support. 

But the remaining Texas vs. Kennedy plaintiff states complain that implementing the updated community integration guidance will “add new regulatory burdens and imposes substantial costs on the state.”

(You know, like how the Canadian government sees disability services as a burden, so it’s incentivizing its disabled citizens to die by (MAiD) euthanasia?)

The Department of Justice has been conferring regularly with these states, and despite community integration being enforced by every administration since the Clinton administration, including the President’s first administration, the DOJ is apparently poised to give these states what they want and more.

Repealing the 2024 guidelines would be destructive enough, but the DOJ has now said that longstanding legal interpretations of Olmstead's community integration mandate are null and void: there is no community integration mandate; states don’t have to serve disabled people in the most integrated setting appropriate to their needs.

For instance, having declined to enforce Olmstead, the Department of Justice has asked the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit to vacate its ruling that Florida illegally withheld the community services necessary for medically fragile children to live at home with their families. A recent court judgment found that Texas violated the law by unnecessarily placing intellectually disabled adults in nursing homes, and the DOJ would like that ruling to be reversed. Alaska, the third state still pursuing the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, was found by the previous administration’s DOJ to have unnecessarily withheld community services from emotionally disabled children. The DOJ will likely seek to nullify that judgment as well.

Hence, the DOJ is failing to protect the same vulnerable people whose flourishing mis being undermined by the euthanasia movement, because that’s what the states of Texas, Florida and Alaska want the DOJ to do.

Incentivizing disabled people to die by assisted suicide violates society’s moral duties to people with disabilities. The current government’s approach to institutionalization also violates those principles. Coercing disabled people into institutions to get your political allies out of a legal pickle is an amoral thing to do.

A lot of people in the current government make vocal appeals to family and moral values. Is forcing intellectually disabled adults to live in understaffed nursing homes that smell like pee, and depriving disabled children of the opportunity to grow up with their families, consistent with those values?

I’m not writing about this issue to shame or praise people for how they vote; my commentary on how other disability issues are related to euthanasia is meant to be nonpartisan. I’ve met people from accross the political spectrum who care about disabled persons.

But recent government choices take steps toward creating a more limited and painful world for people with disabilities. Regardless of anyone’s intentions, making it easier for disabled people to be unnecessarily institutionalized contributes to a culture in which disabled people are so marginalized that offering assisted suicide seems normal and appealing.

It’s unjust to medicalize disabled people’s suicides in order to ease burdens on the medical system.

It’s also immoral for disabled people to shoulder the burden of living in institutions to relieve “regulatory burdens” on the state.

Author Note 1: I did an interview with moral theologian Charlie Camosy about how coerced institutionalization and assisted suicide are connected to one another. It can be read here.

Author Note: Here are the details about the updated Community Integration Mandate that is under threat.
 

Monday, August 17, 2026

No One Has The High Ground On Disability Rights Part 2


By Meghan Schrader
Meghan is a disability activists and a member of the EPC-USA board.

No One Has The High Ground on Disability Rights Part 1 (Link).

Meghan Schrader
Like I’ve said, euthanasia falls on a spectrum of policies that marginalize and objectify people with disabilities. So, when I compare the policies of the United States and Canada, and look at the history of how American leaders from across the political spectrum have treated people with disabilities, I am tempted to despair about disabled people ever being any powerful leaders’ priority. This pattern of marginalization helps create the social conditions that make euthanasia seem like a legitimate solution to disabled people’s problems. 

We know that ableist institutional environments have contributed to coerced euthanasia in Canada. As I’ve mentioned, the USA Justice Department released a slip opinion saying that a 27-year-old federal community integration mandate that states provide enough community support for disabled people to avoid unnecessary institutionalization is essentially null and void; that mandate only forbids “unjustified” institutionalization and states can justify institutionalization however they want. 

In my opinion this development is selfish, bigoted and cruel. But the Province of Ontario in Canada has done the same thing with its More Beds Better Care Act, which allows euthanasia-eligible patients to be forcibly transferred to institutions far away from their families. 

In the past year and a half there have been several instances of USA disability policy regression that push disabled people towards bad life outcomes, and many disability advocates I know would go so far as to view the collective impact of these policies as a kind of authoritarianism. But the Canadian government taking over hospices that decline to participate in euthanizing disabled people that Canada has allowed to live in squalor and misery is no less authoritarian, especially when disabled Canadians have expressed the need for euthanasia-free healthcare spaces. “You had better kill people with disabilities on your property or the government will take over your hospice,” isn’t better than any disability policy being passed or suggested in the United States right now. 

Regardless of which political contingency most strongly influences US social policy, rhetoric that dehumanizes disabled people is everywhere. A conservative-leaning Catholic writer, JD Flynn, whose son has Down Syndrome, posted on X, “You’re not owning the libs by slurring disabled people.”

One X user tweeted back,
“As much as I understand your particular opposition to it, preserving the derogatory use of the word "retard" is in fact necessary for rejecting liberal control of language and defeating the euphemism treadmill which is taking over the English lexicon.”
Another X user wrote,
“Nobody calls disabled people retards anymore. They probably don't even remember what that word means. You're more likely to see a mentally handicapped person call you a retard for this post than to see one be offended by the use of the word.”
Bullies called me a retard when they threw rocks at me, pushed me into the dirt, used my blankie to clean a bathroom floor, pulled down my pants & said that they wished I was dead. I know what the r word means.

And disabled people who have been bullied with the r word do not exist to assist in “rejecting liberal control of language and defeating the euphemism treadmill which is taking over the English lexicon.”

Not that conservatives have a monopoly on this behavior. Remember back in 2008 when the leftist news site Wonkette wrote a despicable blog post about Trig Palin on his birthday?

If you thought that Governor Palin didn’t have the spoons to assume the presidency if Senator McCain died or if you loathed her policy positions that‘s fine, But it wasn’t ok for some liberal to create a vulgar meme taunting that in contrast to the many “retarded” things Palin had said, she had only given birth to one “retarded thing.”

It’s my experience that no matter whether society’s most powerful people identify as conservatives or liberals, leaders habitually ignore disabled people’s needs. This pattern helps create the social conditions for the euthanasia movement to flourish.

Tuesday, July 28, 2026

Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights statement on the ADA and assisted suicide.

Alex Schadenberg
Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

The following message was released by the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) on July 27, 2026.
As we mark the ADA's 36th anniversary, HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) reaffirms a fundamental principle of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): people with disabilities have the same inherent dignity and equal worth as every other person.

The ADA and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act prohibit discrimination based on disability in many settings, including healthcare. Healthcare decisions must not be influenced by stereotypes, bias, or judgments that a person's life is less valuable because of disability. Steering an individual toward physician-assisted suicide because of disability or assumptions about that person's quality of life may constitute unlawful disability discrimination. The Affordable Care Act also prohibits the use of federal funds for physician-assisted suicide, euthanasia, or mercy killing and protects health care providers and entities that decline to participate in those practices.

HHS OCR is committed to enforcing these protections and ensuring that people with disabilities are treated with dignity and respect and receive equal treatment under federal law. If you believe you have experienced disability discrimination in healthcare, you can file a complaint at: hhs.gov/ocr/complaints…
The HHS OCR statement upholds the equality of every American while correctly acknowledging that assisted suicide can be based on discrimination.

The statement also reinforces the federal law prohibiting funding for assisted suicide, euthanasia or mercy killing and the importance of protecting health care providers right to decline to participate in assisted suicide.

The statement focused on three points. Some people with disabilities have felt pressured to assisted suicide. Research has uncovered the fact that the federal law prohibiting funding for assisted suicide is being circumvented. Several state assisted suicide laws, including New York, undermine the right of health care workers to refuse to participate in killing by assisted suicide.

Sunday, July 5, 2026

I am proud to be an American. And I am not disposable.


The text of a speech by Meghan Schrader on July 3rd at an ADAPT of Texas rally to save the 2024 Final Rule’s updates to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.

Meghan Schrader
Meghan Schrader
Disability activist and member of the EPC-USA Board

I am asking Attorney General Paxton to show compassion and respect to disabled people by dropping the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, which seeks to have the 2024 Final Rule’s updates to Section 504 of The Rehabilitation Act, one of our nation’s flagship disability access laws, declared unconstitutional.

Some decent people I’ve tried to talk to about Texas vs. Kennedy dismiss disability advocates’ concerns about this lawsuit as “woke hysteria.” But the accessibility guidelines that are outlined in the Final Rule are not “woke politics” or a culture war issue, they are a matter of human dignity.

The practices outlined in the Final Rule are necessary to meet the human family’s moral obligations to people with disabilities.

The Declaration of Independence says, 
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness."

Monday, May 25, 2026

“The Final Rule, Death And Disability Exclusion: There Is Nothing New Under The Sun”

Meghan Schrader
By Meghan Schrader

Meghan is a disability instructor and a member of the EPC-USA board.

As I’ve said, the Final Rule, a 2024 update to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, especially Sections 84.56(a) and (b), contains some of the best regulations that the euthanasia prevention movement has had at its disposal in decades. Along with new opportunities for everything from home care to internet access, the Final Rule’s regulations elucidate what medical providers must do to make things like x-rays, mammograms, surgery suites, clinics, hospitals and other medical services accessible to disabled patients.

And in a substantial boost to euthanasia prevention, the Final Rule contains prohibitions on futile care laws, infanticide, and doctors “denying or limiting medical treatment based on the provider's belief that the life of a person with a disability has a lesser value than a person without a disability, or that life with a disability is not worth living.”

Yet, in the time since my last blog post about the Final Rule, there have been additional indications that these protections are at risk. As with the Final Rule’s protections for general internet access and better grievance system for disabled people struggling to access home care, the requirement that medical providers make their websites and apps accessible to disabled people has been delayed by the US Department of Health And Human Services.

The government has also indicated that it intends to “reconsider the substantive requirements” of the 2024 Final Rule more broadly. This suggests a risk that all of the Final Rule’s new healthcare accessibility requirements will be rescinded, just as HHS rescinded the Final Rule’s requirement that nursing homes maintain enough staff to prevent residents from experiencing bedsores and malnourishment.

This lackadaisical approach to healthcare accessibility is an absurd blow to euthanasia prevention.

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy has said that Canada’s euthanasia program is “abhorrent.” That’s great, but the government he serves seems happy to dismantle bulwarks against euthanasia.

This is not a partisan statement. Leaders from across the political spectrum make budget cuts and policy decisions that harm people with disabilities. I would write the same things about current disability policies regardless of who controlled the government.

Meanwhile, seven states continue to press ahead with the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, which seeks to repeal the Final Rule, especially its community integration mandate. This mandate is intended to prevent the unnecessary institutionalization of persons with disabilities. It does not require states to close institutions, but it does require them to institute new supports for disabled people at risk of being institutionalized. The plaintiffs are hoping to have a federal judge grant their petition without a full trial.

Texas, Florida, Alaska, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri and Montana,
the states that remain involved in the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, base some of their argument on “states rights.” The states’ attorney generals contend that the Final Rule’s integration mandate encroaches on their “budgetary and policymaking discretion.” They decry the Final Rule's “mandate for states to redesign their Medicaid programs.”

This is an argument for convenience. Texas and Florida, for instance, have some of the highest numbers of institutions in the US; those two states would have to do a lot of work to implement the community integration mandate. Even if there are some people who require institutional care, these states lock disabled people in institutions who don’t need to be there so that the staff can keep their jobs. And the attorney generals in those states wish to export their states’ dysfunction to disabled people across the country, because in their opinion, the best policies serve what’s best for their states, not disabled Americans.

This is what moral theologian Charlie Camosy and Pope Francis call “throwaway culture.”

Euthanasia opponents come from all religions and no religion at all. But I am now going to draw on passages from the Bible because I know that a lot of euthanasia opponents view it as the guidebook for their lives.

In Ecclesiastes 3:16, Solomon writes: “And I saw something else under the sun: In the place of judgment—wickedness was there. in the place of justice—wickedness was there.”

Ecclesiastes 3:16 is a statement about the reality of human injustice. It observes that corruption and wickedness frequently occur in places meant for fairness and righteousness.

That is what is happening when leaders say they oppose euthanasia while dismantling social structures that prevent euthanasia.

Before “MAID” supporters start congratulating themselves on how much more sensitive they think they are to injustice, allow me to direct them to my previous blog post “Many MAiD Proponents Want Credit For Fixing Problems They Ignored For Decades.” Often “MAiD” proponents shout that their cause is a “social justice issue,” yet they have a history of ignoring disability justice.

That’s why they’ve helped create a world where disabled people are offered “MAiD” instead of support.

As I ponder the actions of policymakers who view disabled people as acceptable collateral damage, I find myself reflecting on Ecclesiastes 1:9-“What has been will be again, what has been done will be done will be done again, there is nothing new under the sun.”

This pattern of regressive disability policy decisions is not new; disabled people have been experiencing the same ignominy for generations.

Of course there is a possibility that the Final Rule will not be repealed. Perhaps damage to the USA’s disability inclusion infrastructure can be prevented or repaired. I hope euthanasia opponents will work toward these efforts.

I urge readers to resist cruel policies that consign disabled people to what disability studies scholar Paul Longmore called a “social death.” Instead of allowing disabled people to be abused and ignored, society should base its disability policies on Isaiah 61:1-“He has chosen me and sent me to proclaim good news to the poor, to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim release to captives and freedom to those in prison.”

Author Note:

It may still be possible to save the healthcare non discrimination regulations, and other parts of the Final Rule.

For information about how to contact your attorney general to ask them to drop out of the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, see this link.

To write to the US Department of Justice, use this link

To write to the Department of Health and Hunan Services, use this link.

For a quick explanation of what Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act is, see this Drunk History video about the history of the law.

For a compelling film about the harms of unnecessary institutionalization, watch the 2014 movie Love Land.

You can find a 2023 video of Pope Francis discussing the inclusion and dignity of people with disabilities at this link.

To read the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition’s statement against the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, see this link.

Thursday, May 7, 2026

Nothing about us, without us"

This article was published by Amy Hasbrouck on her substack on May 7, 2026.

Amy Hasbrouck
By Amy Hasbrouck

Get our words out of your mouth.

Rumour has it that the head of Dying with Dignity, Helen Long, invoked an axiom of the disability rights movement in advocating to expand eligibility for euthanasia to people whose requests arise only from a mental illness. Allegedly Ms. Long, who does not identify as disabled, criticized the parliamentary committee for not seeking input from people with mental illness who want government help to ensure fulfillment of their suicidal wishes. Specifically she said the committee had not respected the principle of “Nothing about us, without us.”

(Ms. Long was reading a text by Claire Brosseau, who is a woman who is seeking euthanasia based on mental illness alone).

Say what?

Assuming Ms. Long doesn’t have the lived experience of disability, one would think that, as a woman living in a culture of sexualized violence, she might be able to make the solidarity connection in a more genuine way than by simply claiming it. I get it that the issues raised by euthanasia of people with psychiatric disabilities may be too specialized for folks who are not disabled survivors of childhood trauma and the mental illness that often flows from it. It probably doesn’t occur to Ms. Long that allowing MAiD for people with mental illness undermines the public policy of Suicide prevention, by allowing (often ableist) mental health professionals to judge not just the remediability of a mental illness, but also the person’s quality of life and human worth. And maybe it doesn’t occur to Dying with Dignity that inappropriate or inadequate mental health care means that people with psychiatric disabilities are requesting MAiD because they haven’t gotten the help they need, and are subject to stresses like homelessness, addiction (from attempts at self-medication), and stigmatization.

If Ms. Long really cared about disabled people, she would know that, while some disabled individuals support assisted dying, disability organizations that advocate for equality, acceptance and accessibility oppose medical killing. ADAPT and Not Dead Yet have opposed medical killing since the mid 1980s. The Council of Canadians with Disabilities took its position against legalized medical killing in 1996, at the height of public support for Robert Latimer, who murdered his daughter Tracy in 1993. Surely Ms. Long knows that disability advocates recognize and object to the belief that disabled people are (supposed to be) better off dead, and the growing popularity of assisted dying … as promoted by Dying with Dignity. She would also know that disability advocates are aware that the option to “choose” state-provided euthanasia is fast becoming a duty to die.

If she knew the first thing about ableism, Ms. Long would know that MAiD discriminates against disabled people by definition; disability is among the eligibility criteria enumerated in the definition of a grievous and irremediable medical condition. She would also know that MAiD was provided to many non-terminal disabled people even before the 2019 Truchon decision and the 2021 adoption of Bill C-7, which created “track 2” eligibility for people whose deaths were not “reasonably foreseeable.” Even if Ms. Long didn’t have the advantage of the lived experience of disability discrimination to guide her in evaluating Bill C-14, and its early implementation, anyone who claimed the solidarity of “nothing about us, without us” should have noticed what’s happened in the ten years since legalization; the failure to improve access to palliative care, the reports of same-day euthanasia and MAiD requests linked to “external pressure” (poverty, inadequate and inaccessible housing, and treatment denials) the 100,000 euthanasia deaths and the transformation of an “exceptional” measure to an “expected” response.

When people’s livelihood and self-image depends on not understanding something, they probably won’t understand it. Apparently, Ms. Long’s personal, pecuniary and political interests depend on her not knowing that it is very uncool to appropriate a disability rights principle in advocating a position the disability rights movement strongly opposes.

So please, get our words out of your (nasty) mouth.

Amy Hasbrouck is the director of Toujours Vivant - Not Dead Yet and a past-President of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition. 

Wednesday, April 22, 2026

Repealing the Final Rule Would Be Tragedy For Opposition To Euthanasia.

Meghan Schrader
By Meghan Schrader

As I’ve mentioned, the Final Rule, a 2024 update to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, is one of the best tools that the anti euthanasia movement has had in decades. The Final Rule strengthens Section 504 and the Americans With Disabilities Act in several ways, including new prohibitions against medical personnel pushing disabled people towards death. These provisions are new bulwarks against assisted suicide, coerced DNRs, futile care statutes and the infanticide of disabled babies; such as in the 1982 Baby Doe case. Everything groups opposing euthanasia need to avoid a Canada-like situation is in those regulations.

The Final Rule not only addresses futile care statutes, assisted suicide and infanticide, it also contains numerous other beneficial provisions. For instance, the Final Rule contains new protections for disabled parents, internet access, accessible medical equipment and better community services for disabled people at risk of being institutionalized. Hence, the Final Rule will help protect disabled Americans from the scarcity that is pushing disabled Canadians towards euthanasia.

But in 2025, 17 states filed the Texas vs. Becerra lawsuit, now called Texas vs. Kennedy. The original lawsuit sought to repeal the entire Final Rule, as well as Section 504 itself. (The challenge to Section 504 itself was dropped after backlash.)

In addition to multiple disability protections that I think EPC blog readers from across the political spectrum can agree on, one clause of the Final Rule defined gender dysphoria as a disability. This was one of the reasons that the 17 states filed suit against the Final Rule.

But the gender dysphoria issue is currently a moot point. Regardless of whether one believes that gender dysphoria ought to be defined as an impairment, the President’s executive order on gender issues means that this government will not enforce that part of the Rule. So, eight of the original 17 states dropped out of the lawsuit.

But 9 states still want to eliminate the rest of the Final Rule. Texas, Florida, Alaska, Indiana, Missouri, Louisiana, Kansas, Montana and South Dakota want the government to avoid “burdening” states with the Rule’s requirement that states institute new supports for disabled people at risk of being institutionalized. So, on January 23rd, 2026, those states filed an updated version of their lawsuit. This iteration of the lawsuit makes no mention of gender dysphoria or repealing Section 504 itself, but it still seeks to have the entire Final Rule set aside.

I am also very worried that even if the lawsuit is dropped, HHS and the Department of Justice will rescind the entire Final Rule anyway.

This would be a shame, because the Final Rule is a critical tool for achieving opposition to euthanasia.

Groups opposing euthanasia have always fought the infanticide of disabled babies, which we know happens periodically in hospitals across the US and abroad because doctors make prejudiced judgments about the value of the babies’ lives. (Such as the UK Alfie Evans case.) Section 84.56 specifically addresses this problem. To quote from the text of the Final Rule:

“Comments: Several commenters asked the Department to clarify the application of § 84.56 to newborn infants.

Response: As indicated within the NPRM, the Department considers section 504, including § 84.56, to apply to newborn infants. This includes the prohibitions against the denial of medical treatment under § 84.56(b)(1) and (2), and the prohibitions on the discriminatory provision of medical treatment under § 84.56(b)(3).

Comment: One commenter objected based on its understanding that the Department's proposed rule would not apply to decisions to withhold treatment from infants with disabilities in which the disabling condition is related to the condition to be treated, noting that § 84.56(b)(2) addresses treatment for a separately diagnosable condition or symptom and not for the underlying disability. The comment concerned infants with disability conditions such as meningomyelocele, hydrocephaly, microcephaly, or other anatomical anomalies. The comment noted that failure to treat these conditions represents discrimination against a child with a disability.

Response: The Department believes that this comment misconstrues the section 504 rule. The Department intends that this rule will generally apply to the provision of medical treatment for infants, including those seeking treatment for separately diagnosable symptoms or conditions related to their underlying disability, when medical treatment is provided to other similarly situated children. For example, an infant with microcephaly may experience seizures. This would constitute a separately diagnosable symptom or condition for which treatment would be subject to the protections of § 84.56(b)(2) despite the fact that the seizures are a symptom of the infant's microcephaly. As the Department's NPRM made clear, with respect to separately diagnosable conditions, the rule will not require that the condition be entirely unrelated to the underlying disability. “Nor does it matter for these purposes whether the condition for which the individual is seeking treatment is in some sense causally related to the underlying disability if the decision to refuse treatment would not be made as to similarly situated individuals without the disability.” 88 FR 63405. In addition, § 84.56(b)(1) prohibits denying or limiting medical treatment to a qualified individual with a disability based on bias or stereotypes about that patient's disability, judgments that the individual will be a burden on others due to their disability, or a belief that the life of a person with a disability has a lesser value than the life of a person without a disability or that life with a disability is not worth living. Under such circumstances, the discrimination described by the commenter would also be covered under § 84.56(b)(1) even if the condition for which the patient sought treatment was not a separately diagnosable symptom or condition from their underlying disability.”
So, if you are fighting infanticide, the Final Rule is your best friend. 

Opposition to euthanasia has also always fought futile care laws, like those that exist in Texas and California, which allow hospital ethics committees to override patients’ and families’ desires for life-saving care that ableist physicians consider “futile.” For instance, the anti-futility provisions in the Final Rule were inspired by the case of Michael Hickson, who was denied treatment for COVID-19 because he was a quadriplegic. The Final Rule forbids such authoritarianism. It is the anti euthanasia movement’s best shot at eliminating futile care laws once and for all.

An excerpt about the Final Rule’s prohibition on medical futility reads as follows:

“The Department proposed §  84.56(b)(1)(iii) to prohibit recipients from denying or limiting medical treatment based on the provider's belief that the life of a person with a disability has a lesser value than a person without a disability, or that life with a disability is not worth living.

Comments: The Department received a broad array of comments from disability organizations, civil rights organizations, and other stakeholders supporting this approach. We received stories from people with disabilities describing their own experiences or those of friends regarding the denial of life-sustaining treatment and the difficulties involved in accessing it after such denials. We also received similar stories from providers. For example, one provider association described a 25-year-old patient with a developmental disability who had been referred to an inpatient hospice unit after becoming poorly responsive with brain imaging demonstrating a shunt and severe abnormalities. After the provider learned from a family member of a recent sudden change in the patient's behavior, the patient received a second opinion, leading to the shunt being surgically revised, the patient's condition improving, and her enjoying her life for many more years. In the words of this commenter, the patient's “referral to hospice without sufficient exploration of other treatment options was inappropriate and may have been driven by a mistaken clinical assumption regarding her baseline quality of life.”

Response: The Department will retain the provision as proposed. We respond to specific questions regarding the application of this requirement throughout this section.”
Hence, this section of the Final Rule forbids the futile care impositions that groups opposing euthanasia have fought for decades.

Moreover, we know that disabled Canadians are agreeing to be killed by “MAiD” because they aren’t getting the supports they need: not having wheelchairs, pain control, food, housing, jobs, etc. These conditions also contribute to high rates of suicide among US citizens with disabilities. Hence, the Final Rule helps prevent disabled Americans from experiencing Canada-like tragedies.

And, given that the Final Rule prohibits federal funding recipients from “from denying or limiting medical treatment based on the provider's belief that the life of a person with a disability has a lesser value than a person without a disability, or that life with a disability is not worth living,” it precludes turning disabled people’s suicides into a “medical procedure.” Think of the efforts we will have to expend against assisted suicide in the future: wouldn’t you like to use the Final Rule to fight those bills?

I urge other euthanasia opponents to do what they can to defend the Final Rule. Time is of the essence, because many of the regulations in the Final Rule are supposed to take effect this month and federal officials have already eliminated or delayed some of them. For instance, officials have rescinded new provisions requiring adequate staffing in nursing homes. New rules about internet access and home and community based services have also been paused. Therefore, the aforementioned anti-death provisions could soon be paused or eliminated as well.

So, if you are someone in Washington DC who interacts with officials at HHS or the Department of Justice, make the importance of the Final Rule part of your conversations. If you live in one of the states that is bringing the Texas vs. Kennedy lawsuit, write to your attorney general and ask them to drop it.

The Final Rule furthers compassion and dignity for disabled persons. It is also one of the USA’s most urgent anti-euthanasia issues in decades.

Author Note:

For information about how to contact your attorney general to ask them to drop the lawsuit, see this link.

To write to the US Department of Justice, go to this link.

To write to the Department of Health and Hunan Services, use this link.
For a quick explanation of what Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act is, see this Drunk History video about the history of the law. 

Meghan is a disability instructor and a member of the EPC-USA board.