Friday, May 3, 2013

Medical Serial Killer, nurse, Charles Cullen: 'I thought I was helping'

The Daily mail published the following article concerning Charles Cullen, a nurse who was also a medical serial killer in the United States. This article was published on April 29 under the title: 'Angel of Death' nurse who murdered at least 40 patients to become one of America's worst serial killers speaks from prison for the first time to chillingly claim: 'I thought I was helping.'

  • Cullen is not alone, as a medical serial killer. Dr Michael Swango is believed to have killed 35 - 60 patients, and similar to Cullen, he was simply asked to resign, or moved to another location. Aino Nykopp-Koski is a nurse who was convicted of killing 5 patients in Finland. On March 28, 2013 Dr Virginia Soares de Souza was arrested in Brazil and is suspected of killing 300 patients. Then there is Dr Harold Shipman, who was convicted of killing 15 patients in England but is suspected to have killed between 250 and 400 of his patients. Then there is the case of William Melchert-Dinkel, the Minnesota nurse who was convicted of 2 counts of assisted suicide for counselling depressed people to commit suicide.

  • Why do medical killers go undetected for so long? 

  • When I read the Pulitzer Prize winning book by James B. Stewart's, Blind Eye - The Terrifying Story of a Doctor Who Got Away With Murder it was clear that the medical community has a hard time believing that one of their own could do such acts. They also fear lawsuits and they fear that they will also be accused of being complicit in the acts by not effectively protecting their patients.

  • How can society even consider legalizing euthanasia or assisted suicide and thereby giving medical professionals, the right in law to cause the death or being involved with causing the death of their patients. This would provide cover for murder, which may or may not be done with the consent of the patient?

  • Considering this information and considering the fact that the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition regularly receives phone calls or emails from people claiming that similar crimes have happened to their loved ones or friends, and considering the information in the recently released book: After the Error: Speaking out about patient safety to save lives. How could anyone who cares about the safety of vulnerable people support the legalization of euthanasia or assisted suicide?

  • Further to that one must also consider that recent statistics showing that, where euthanasia is legal that: Euthanasia is out of control in the Netherlands, and the number of Euthanasia deaths increased by 25% in Belgium in 2012.

    Consider the three recent studies from the Flanders region of Belgium that found:
    1. 32% of all euthanasia deaths were done without explicit request.
    1. 47% of all euthanasia deaths were not reported as euthanasia.
    1. Nurses are euthanizing their patients, even though the Belgium law limits the act of euthanasia to doctors
    It is simply not safe for society to legalize euthanasia or assisted suicide.

  • Daily Mail Report, April 29, 2013. Link to the article.

  • * Charles Cullen is known as the most prolific serial killer in American history
  • * It is believed he could have killed up to 400 patients by injecting them with lethal medication. 
  • * Went undetected for 16 years.
  • * Finally caught in 2003 and given six life sentences in 2006.

  • Charles Cullen
    A nurse who admitted killing at least 40 patients in his care but is suspected of murdering hundreds apologized for the deaths in his first ever interview from jail but still claimed they were mercy killings.

    Charles Cullen was handed down six life sentences in 2006 after he admitted poisoning at least 40 people in New Jersey and Pennsylvania over the course of his 16-year nursing career.

    Considered one of the most prolific serial killers in American history and once dubbed 'the angel of death', Cullen said he wanted to end his patients' suffering, even though many of them were in good health.

    The serial killer was interviewed for the first time ever about the murders by CBS' 60 Minutes, which was aired last night.

    When asked if he considered himself a murderer, he said: 'I think that I had a lot of trouble accepting that word for a long time. I accept that that's what it is.'

    When asked if he got pleasure out of killing people, Cullen told 60 Minutes: 
    'No, I thought that people weren't suffering anymore. So, in a sense, I thought I was helping.'
    When it was pointed out that many of his patients weren't in pain, he said: 
    'You know, again, you know, I mean, my goal here isn't to justify. 
    'You know what I did there is no justification. I just think that the only thing I can say is that I felt overwhelmed at the time.'
    In the interview broadcast on CBS' 60 Minutes, Cullen admits that if he had not been stopped, he probably would have went on to kill more people.

    At the time of his arrest in December 2003, Cullen told authorities he had administered overdoses to patients to spare them from going into cardiac or respiratory arrest.

    Even though there were suspicions at several of the hospitals he worked at, these were never reported or marked on his record and Cullen was able to continue his killing spree at each place he was transferred to.

    When Cullen was hired at Saint Luke's University Hospital in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, he had already been fired or forced to resign from five other hospitals. 

    Yet none of this was in his file with the state nursing board. 

    He admits to killing five people at St Lukes and even though there were suspicions, the hospital asked him to resign on the premise they would give him neutral references.

    He was then hired as a critical care nurse at New Jersey's Somerset Medical Center, where he administered lethal injections to 13 patients over 13 months.

    It was only when a Roman Catholic priest named Florian Gall died unexpectedly overnight while recovering from pneumonia, that the hospital discovered high levels of the heart drug digoxin in his blood.

    It was the second unexplained overdose in two weeks and set in motion the events leading up to Cullen's arrest.

    Asked why he thought he was able to go undetected for so long, he said: 
    'I think because it's a matter of worrying about lawsuits.  
    If they pointed out that there was a problem they were going to be found liable for millions of dollars. They just saw it as a lot easier to not put themselves in a position of getting sued.'
    He also revealed that when he was at Somerset, he was allowed to work one more shift even though he was being fired over the suspicious deaths.
    'The weird thing about Somerset Hospital was is that they were planning on firing me the night before. So they let me work one more shift knowing that they were going to fire me the next day,' he told 60 Minutes. 
    'So they let me work an additional shift with the suspicion that I had harmed patients. Which I, you know, was kind of a bizarre thing to do.'

    Link to the 60 minutes interview promo:


    Winston said...

    The anti-choice community is responsible for far more deaths. By their continued, ironclad opposition to assisted dying, they are, in effect, forcing sufferers of ALS, MS etc. to take their lives sooner.

    Why should they be forced to die "naturally" under palliative care when palliative care has been proven to be far from adequate in many cases?

    Alex Schadenberg said...

    Winston likes to make comments that he has no proof of and without any concern for the fact that we are trying to protect people and he is trying to kill people.

    Winston said...

    You aren't protecting anyone by keeping draconian laws in place. With no oversight and a loophole big enough to fit the US military in, you are advocating policies that result in more deaths without consent than would occur under a system with safeguards.