Friday, August 28, 2020

Tasmania bill will allow wide-open euthanasia.

Alex Schadenberg
Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

(Tasmania is an Australian Island state).

When debating the legalization of euthanasia or assisted suicide, the specific language of the legislation is often overlooked while people debate the concept assisted death.

The language in the 122 page Tasmania End of Life Choices bill which is expected to have its second reading in the Upper House on September 15, allows for a wide open assisted death regime.

This article focuses on the definition of medical condition in the bill.

For the purposes of the Act, the bill defines a relevant medical condition as:
(1) a disease, illness, injury, or medical condition, of the person that is serious, incurable and irreversible. 
(2)Despite subsection(1), a mental illness, within the meaning of the Mental Health Act 2013 is not a relevant medical condition for the purposes of this Act.
What does that mean? Unless the request for assisted death is based on mental illness, the person is only required to have a serious, incurable and irreversible medical condition.

The bill states that a person must be suffering intolerably in relation to a relevant medical condition. However, this is completely subjective because the bill states that the intolerable suffering is solely determined by the opinion of the person requesting assisted death

The bill also states that a person can be approved for an assisted death not only based on the serious, incurable and irreversible condition but also based on complications that may arise from treatment being received or treatment that may possibly be received.

Specifically, the bill states that a person can be approved for an assisted death if that person is concerned about:

"complications that have arisen, or may arise, in relation to the treatment of the relevant medical condition or its treatment or the combination of that treatment with the treatment of other medical conditions of the person."
The bill goes on to state that assisted death is permitted if, in the opinion of the person making the request, there is no reasonable treatment that will lessen the persons suffering to an extent that is acceptable to the person.

Therefore a person can be approved for an assisted death based on a fear of suffering related to a possible effective treatment, that the person has not tried. The caveat being that the person may in fact not only forgo the effective treatment but have never considered it in the first place.

Some people are delusional or have nosophobia about their medical condition. As noted above stated the language of the bill allows a wide open assisted death regime.

In summary, the definition of medical condition is completely subjective because it is based on whether the person finds the condition unacceptable, which is impossible for a physician to evaluate.

In other words, this bill gives pro-euthanasia medical practitioners the ability to approve deaths without fear of wrongful deaths leading to legal concerns.

The Tasmanian assisted death bill is 122 pages long. It is a massive spider web of text that appears to have comprehensive safeguards. 

This voluminous bill is not designed to protect a vulnerable person, but rather to protect medical practitioners who choose to kill.

1 comment:

sophie jensen said...

I live in Australia, although not in Tasmania (or Victoria), and I am very, very worried. As someone pointed out to me a while back, if the situation was out of hand BEFORE any bills to legalise Euthanasia, what will it be like when they do bring it into law? Witness the notion that Aged Care Residents with an NFR Order are not taken to hospital, but just left in situ, to meet whatever fate awaits them. The response is 'Oh, they had NFR in place, so they did not want treatment'. A Vicious Circle to beat all Vicious Circles. Isn't it a right to treatment, and if the treatment does not work, then the NFR Order kicks in? Not according to what I am seeing. Actually, I am too scared to seek medical assistance for my minor ailments. Lucky I don't yet have any major ones. I find the current trends immensely scary.