International Chair, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition
The 2014 annual report is similar to prior years. The preamble implies that the deaths were voluntary (self-administered), but the information reported does not address that subject.
Oregon's assisted suicide law allows the lethal dose to be administered without oversight. This creates the opportunity for an heir, or someone else who will benefit from the patient's death, to administer the lethal dose to the patient without the patient's consent. "Even if he struggled, who would know?"
In 2014, Assisted suicide's in Oregon increased in numbers, conditions and demographics.
- 105 assisted suicide deaths in 2014 up from 73 in 2013. (44% increase).
- 155 prescriptions for suicide in 2014 up from 105 in 2013. (48% increase).
In previous years almost 80% of the deaths, were cancer related. In 2014, 68% had cancer with "other illnesses" increasing to 8.6% (9 deaths). Other illnesses includes diabetes.
The number of people who had private health insurance and died by assisted suicide dropped from 60% in previous years to 40% in 2014.
Similar to previous years, only 3 people received a psychiatric evaluation. An Oregon study found that 26% of those who request assisted suicide are depressed.
Statistics concerning other suicides indicate that assisted suicide is having a suicide contagion effect.
A recent article by the disability rights group Not Dead Yet stated that the Oregon assisted suicide law is discriminatory and a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. The most common reasons for assisted suicide requests are disability related.
In only 14 of 105 deaths, the prescribing physician was present at the death. There is little oversight or protection in Oregon.
In Oregon, the doctor who prescribes suicide self-reports the assisted suicide death after the person has died. Since doctors do not self-report abuse of the law and since the doctor is rarely at the death, therefore we have no idea if the assisted suicide death was voluntary and we have no idea if the persons who died were mentally competent, depressed or coerced.
The lack of oversight reveals concerns that elders, who are being abused, may be dying by assisted suicide.
Similar to other years, the 2014 Oregon assisted suicide leaves us with more questions than answers.
As Mark Twain once said: "There are lies, damn lies, and statistics" Yes, going from 1 to 2 would be a 100% increase, but it"s disingenuous to base comments about "shocking" increases on a statistically small sample. Why, in previous years, when the number of deaths declined, didn't Mr. Schadenberg tout those figures? He could have even claimed it as a victory of sorts. It is unfortunate that those who oppose aid in dying have little more than fear to promote their cause, but that may be why they are loosing the battle.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, I never publish Anonymous comments but since yours is so foolish I thought it was best to publish it.
ReplyDelete1. I never used the term shocking.
2. I only published the facts.
3. I published the facts last year.
4. It is not about fear, it is about protecting people.
5. I would not trust you with my life.
What will happen to Canada's First Nations and their skyrocketing suicide rates? Is the SCC's horrific decision the "final solution" to those who clearly need help?
ReplyDelete